Smoothies vs Juicing: Which is Better?

Are smoothies always healthier than juices, and if not, in what circumstances should you drink juices versus smoothies?

Let’s answer this tricky question.

Now, smoothies, and especially green smoothies or smoothies with all kinds of powders are all the craze.

Juice extractors are not as popular as they used to be, but still can have their place in your health routine.

So when should you juice, and when should you blend?


Juicing removes all the fiber from the fruits or vegetables you’re putting through your extractor.

This can offer some benefit for those with compromised digestion, because fresh juices retain most of their nutrients, and yet are highly absorbable and easily digestible.

The downside is that fresh juices containing a lot of sugar (carrot or fruit juices) are liquid calories without fiber.

This means that consuming calorie-rich juices can make you gain weight, or can upset your blood sugar.

If you’re going to juice a lot, stay away from carrot and fruit juices.

You can use one carrot or one apple to sweeten a green juice, but don’t make it the base of your juice.

Green juices are an excellent way to obtain quality minerals, antioxidants, and improve your nutrition with one tall glass a day.

A hint of sweetness is permitted, but keep it green!

Instead, add lemon and Tabasco sauce to spice things up a bit.

However… fruit juices has its place. Here are the circumstances allowing for fresh fruit juices:

– As a treat

– After or during a workout, especially one where you burn a lot of calories. Watermelon juice is excellent for long-distance running, with added electrolytes in it.

– During a juice cleanse or detox, to get some calories and energy.

– After a fast or detox diet

– If you’re trying to gain weight or if you’re particularly active

Other than that… keep your juices green!


The advantage of smoothies is that they keep all of their fiber. But be careful… too much blending and that fiber will be broken down so much that it will lose its structure.

The body will treat that fruit smoothie much like a fruit juice.

Smoothies should be liquid meals. Unless you’re preparing for a big workout, don’t just drink a tall glass of fruit smoothie. Add other elements to it, like green vegetables (such as spinach).

Smoothies can be a great way to get in your greens AND your fruit intake for the day in an easy way, keeping all the fiber and most of the nutrients intact.

One way to achieve all-day energy is to bypass the digestive burden we face every day by liquefying some of your meals.

Enjoyed this article?

Check out the real-world-tested recipes in The Raw Dinner Recipes eBook. Get 16 quick and delicious oil-free recipes that will help balance your weight and make you feel great!

You can get it right now – for FREE! – by clicking the banner below.



3 Responses

  1. May i know is it smoothies filling last longer?
    is it suitable for diet weightloss without any side effect or loss nutrietion?

  2. Rhonda Moore says:

    I have just begun smoothies in place of juicing. I balanced -colors of the rainbow- when juicing. I have not juiced only during my day- added a smoothie. I drink 32.oz juice and 2) 32.smoothies now without juicing. I am extremely tired and hungry with smoothies and while juicing I had energy.
    Also headaches with smoothies, which I don’t understand. Possibly not making smoothies correctly- I love a balance of veggie and fruit; green juice was one of my favorites.

  3. Celery juice every morning on an empty stomach does wonders, other that that I don’t do fruit juices, rather eat the fruit, and do not do smoothies either, I eat the food!